Gentrification in process: the financialization of housing in the Global City

As the world is increasingly becoming more urbanizedthe interrelationship between population growth and housing development has imposed unprecedented challenges for many cities worldwide. Ideally, public policies must ensure access to housing for all, but in fact, what we have witnessed is an alarming increase in homelessness and inadequate housing that often are directly linked to embedded patterns of discrimination, colonization, and marginalization. In recent years, housing systems around the world have been profoundly transformed by a phenomenon known as “the financialization of housing” in which housing has become a commodity to be bought, sold, and priced as a portfolio asset for speculation, rather than being traded according to its value as a social good (FAHRA, L. 2017). 

Private financial corporations and offshore investors often purchase a massive number of existing modest houses (often occupied by minority and marginalized groups) based on the convenient justification that renovations would bring development for those communities. In reality, what happens is that they dramatically increase the market rental and purchase value of these properties, making them unaffordable for those same communities. Such scenario is part of a perverse and very well-structured plan to attract more “advantaged” higher-income householders, which both exploit inequalities and reinforce socio-economic segregation.

Figure 1. A sign sits outside of Welch Park in Atlanta calling for an end to gentrification. Image source: https://www.gpb.org/news/2019/11/27/equity-advocate-economist-share-different-views-of-gentrification. Retrieved on November 9th, 2021.

In her investigation about the effects of the global economy on major cities, the Dutch-American sociology Saskia Sassen highlighted this trend of reshaping the city as this valuable commodity based on new modes of privatizing urban spaces where property regimes led by wealthy investors have been mining the capacity of the working and lower classes to find affordable houses. Exploring the concept of “deurbanization of the urban space” Sassen also states the weak utility function of existing properties that are purchased and renovated by large-scale corporates: many of these houses are left empty on purpose as a speculative way of storing capital which is considered one of the best investments for the elites.

These new exclusionary real estate practices and large-scale acquisitions of urban land and housing stock have established new frontiers in major cities where the low and middle classes have no choice than to occupy peripheral and more affordable spaces - “an ambiguous zone of mostly low-rise, poor-quality housing that is neither city nor slum” (SASSEN, 2016).

Figure 2. New frontiers between “the periphery” and the “formal” city in São Paulo - the largest and most populated city in Brazil. Image source: Paloma Vasconcelos/Ponte Jornalismo. https://www.observatoriodasmetropoles.net.br/mortalidade-por-covid-19-em-sao-paulo-ainda-rumo-a-periferia-do-municipio/ Retrieved on November 9th, 2021.

References

SASSEN, Saskia. The city: a collective good. Brown J. World Aff., v. 23, 2016.

FARHA, L; PORTER, B. Commodification over community: financialization of the housing sector and its threat to SDG 11 and the right to housing in Spotlight on Sustainable Development, 2017.

Alleviating Urban Economic Hardships: Stockton’s 24-month UBI Experiment Offers A New Template

Starting in February 2019, the City of Stockton began the SEED initiative, a 24-month pilot program giving 125 people who were at or below the median income level, $500 a month. This payment differed from pre-existing social welfare programs as there was no work requirement and the payments were unconditional. The key findings from this program include:

·       Guaranteed income reduced income volatility, or the month-to-month income fluctuations that households face.

·       Unconditional cash enabled recipients to find full-time employment.

·       Recipients of guaranteed income were healthier, showing less depression and anxiety and enhanced wellbeing.

·       The guaranteed income alleviated financial scarcity creating new opportunities for self-determination, choice, goal-setting, and risk-taking.

(West et al. 2021; pp.1)

So, what does this mean for urban planning? I posit that we, as planners, can utilize this increased level of risk-taking to further substantiate our experiments in new urban forms and practices. One major hurdle in planning is lack of public participation, and programs like UBI could possibly increase the likelihood of people participating in other experimental urban practices, creating more optimal conditions for planners to gain applicable knowledge about their constituents.

Infographic on the participants and impacts of the SEED program. Image Source: The Appeal; https://theappeal.org/universal-basic-income-stockton-pandemic/

Infographic on the participants and impacts of the SEED program. Image Source: The Appeal; https://theappeal.org/universal-basic-income-stockton-pandemic/

Reference

West, S., Castro Baker, A., Samra, S., & Coltrera, E. (2021). Preliminary Analysis: SEED’s First Year. stocktondemonstration.org. Retrieved 2021, from https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6039d612b17d055cac14070f/t/603ef1194c474b329f33c329/1614737690661/SEED_Preliminary+Analysis-SEEDs+First+Year_Final+Report_Individual+Pages+-2.pdf

Centers of Economic Opportunity: Exploring Streams of Income

Cities have repeatedly been referred to as centers of economic opportunity – a trait not to be shed anytime soon. Through efficient infrastructure and services, urban agglomerations function as clusters of knowledge, innovation, transportation, and communication. Consequently, cities' dense accessibility to resources and technology facilitates and diversifies individuals' potential means of revenue, primarily through earned, portfolio, and passive income.

Since the COVID-19 outbreak, however, individual's functioning in private and social spheres vastly changed, mainly since the whole world was confined at home. With re-organizing how we go about the world during a pandemic, the economic domain was significantly impacted. Several were limited by the safety precautions and experienced hardships, like loss of employment. But, on the other hand, some also utilized this circumstance to explore, learn, and adopt new skills.

One of many fields to have gain popularity is real estate investment. Over the past two years, the Canadian market has flourished with wide purchasing options and great interest rates, giving people in diverse economic positions more opportunities. Investing in a primary residence, short-term rental, or long-term rental property can maximize your income in the long run and also contribute to the country's economy. Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT) is also a considerable alternative for investing in the market without physically holding a house. These options have also often been a safer venture than other investing routes like stocks. Note, risks and benefits must always be weighed. All investment opportunities come with uncertainties, which underlies the importance for all to convey proper research. Reaching out to advising and consulting resources is also chiefly recommended.

Montreal, Canada, has become prized for its luxury market. Indeed, the global destination's distinguished cultural diversity, employment opportunities, educational institutions, and serene quality of life have increasingly enticed locals and foreigners to invest in the land (Sharma, 2021). Photograph: Loïc Romer (N/A)

Montreal, Canada, has become prized for its luxury market. Indeed, the global destination's distinguished cultural diversity, employment opportunities, educational institutions, and serene quality of life have increasingly enticed locals and foreigners to invest in the land (Sharma, 2021). Photograph: Loïc Romer (N/A)

With resources made available more than ever, maximizing your revenue has become a matter of drive, persistence, and determination. The remaining question is, what skill can you apply or learn to expand your income?

References

Pipe, T. (2021). Is real estate a good investment in Canada? Canadian Real Estate Wealth https://www.canadianrealestatemagazine.ca/expert-advice/is-real-estate-a-good-investment-in-canada-334551.aspx

Sharma, N. (2021). Montreal is Canada’s leading luxury market: Engel & Völkers. Canadian Real Estate Wealth https://www.canadianrealestatemagazine.ca/news/montreal-is-canadas-leading-luxury-market-engel-and-volkers-334770.aspx

Image Reference

Romer, L. (N/A). Montreal. AirTransat https://www.airtransat.com/en-GB/visit-canada/montreal?search=flight&flightType=RT&pax=1-0-0-0